The Sakinorva Databank
home index activity
random rules donate

Ian MacKaye

Musician

in Music and Performing Arts

Ian MacKaye ~ Sakinorva Databank

Ian MacKaye


Musician

ei
ns
ft
pj
functionenneavariantsociopsyche
ISFP 1
6w7 2
1w9 1
LSI 1
234 567 891
h
e
x
a
c
o

total votes 10

4

1

3

1

1

Click to toggle markup guide.

bold**bold**
italic*italic*
hyperlink to "contextualizing functions"[hyperlink to "contextualizing functions"](https://sakinorva.net/library/contextualizing_functions)
(i){https://i.imgur.com/g0oL9CB.png}
You may not modify this entry's picture.

LadyX

intp

5

2019/07/25 (Thu) 05:18:24

#6697

I can see basing a typing on some of the Minor Threat lyrics as "FP". 

But if you look at the impact and vision of MacKaye himself, extroverted thinking is the dominant force.  The rest of the ENTJ function stack makes sense as well (Te - Ni - Se - Fi) -  even with the introverted feeling at the bottom. 

"ENTJ = Reformers - Determined, Energetic, Strategic, Outgoing" - Sounds like Ian

"ISFP = Harmonizers - Tolerant, Realistic, Harmonious, Adaptable" - Does not sound like Ian

His ethos is not really centered on spontaneity - it focuses on being true to yourself and others, being community-minded, not exploiting others, standing up for what is right.  Enneagram type 1.

Perhaps the ISFP typing is due to a jumbled stack misinterpretation (Fi - Se - Ni - Te).

Editing post #6697 by LadyX

Replying to post #6697 by LadyX

Eon

INFP

2019/07/24 (Wed) 12:06:12

#6691

ENTJ because he organizes things ? 'cause only TJ can get shit done ?

his whole ethos is centered on values and spontaneity 

pretty obvious FP tough I'm not sure if there's any basis for I or S (except Minor Threat being simple and direct)

Editing post #6691 by Eon

Replying to post #6691 by Eon

switchblades

INFP

delete

2018/10/13 (Sat) 23:19:29

#3639

So you are real... hello!

Editing post #3639 by switchblades

Replying to post #3639 by switchblades

LadyX

intp

5

2018/10/13 (Sat) 16:21:10

#3637

Way out there on the idealism end of the spectrum - isn't he a classic 1?  With the anger and outrage of a 1 and the reformer attitude?

Also - a leader of a movement based on bringing up lots of other musicians - ENTJ fits.  Entrepreneur, front person, coordinator.

" MacKaye recorded and distributed his bands’ music, as well as the music of other bands in his hometown of Washington D.C., such as Government Issue, Scream, Marginal Man and Jawbox. And he insisted that shows be all ages and that ticket and album prices be affordable so that his music and performances would be accessible to the kids who made up the hardcore scene."

 

Editing post #3637 by LadyX

Replying to post #3637 by LadyX

dateusernamevote
18/10/13 16:06LadyX ENTJ
18/07/09 02:55scumfuc IxFP
19/07/24 12:06Eon xNFP
18/05/03 08:42the heart marksman ISFP
dateusernamevote
19/07/24 12:12Eon ISFP
dateusernamevote
18/10/13 16:07LadyX 1w9
18/07/09 02:55scumfuc 6w7
18/05/09 12:52EON 6w7
dateusernamevote
18/10/13 16:08LadyX 351
dateusernamevote
18/07/09 02:56scumfuc LSI